Helpful read on the warning signs of suicide


Sunday’s lead story in the Philadelphia Inquirer unfolds the tragic story of two high school girls who committed suicide by stepping in front of a speeding train last winter. The death of a child is always a tragedy. But death by suicide exponentially multiplies the pain. Could anyone see it coming? Could they have prevented it?

The story in the paper details the texts and social networking trail of tears leading up to their final actions. If this event happened when I was a child, the parents might have been left with a note or a journal to pour over looking for clues. But, in this case, there are texts and posts over a long span of time. Even worse, the girls made a number of final texts just before their deaths. It appears that loved ones searched frantically for them while “watching” cyberspace during their final act. I can only imagine that this “real time” aspect multiplies the trauma for the family.

Can we learn anything from this? Yes, I think so.

  1. Pay attention to your child’s (or friend’s) social networking and texts. Clues to their state of mind may well be evident.
  2. Act on concerns; take stock of their actions and attitudes. Per this case, it appears there were efforts to help them. Probably not enough. But let us not judge the family here. It is far too easy to become complacent. A child has strong feelings that they express over a period of time, thus making suicidal expressions normal. After the fact the signs seem so obvious. During the stress, it is hard to discern how bad it really is.
  3. Compounding suffering requires additional interventions, whether the child wants it or not. One girl’s father committed suicide, parents’ divorced requiring a move and change of school, a boyfriend was killed by a car. The more these kinds of experiences happen, the more attention the child needs by mentor or mental health workers.
  4. Even good schools won’t likely pick up on problems. Don’t assume school counselors have enough time to respond. It is not that they are incapable but the sheer number of students to follow makes their capacities limited.

Know that some people commit suicide and no one could have predicted it. Be wary of judging family members. They will live with enough guilt on their own. And yet, look for this recipe of pain and perceptions (summary of Jeff Black’s booklet):

  1. Strong powerful experiences of pain
  2. Perception that the they cannot tolerate the pain
  3. Hopelessness and inability to see alternatives other than relief via suicide
  4. Isolation

Other risk factors to consider: previous attempt? Suicidal ideation/plan? Hospitalization (even for non-psychiatric reasons)? Access to lethal means? Depressive anger coupled with impulsive history. These factors aren’t that helpful by themselves but looking over the total may provide *some* clues.

2 Comments

Filed under counseling, counseling science, counseling skills, Depression, Psychology, Relationships, Uncategorized

2 responses to “Helpful read on the warning signs of suicide

  1. Jessica Meade

    Phil,

    Thanks for touching on this, it is so importnat. I would also like to put a “plug” in for watching for suicidal warning signs in the elderly population. I think as a counselor, I always placed emphasis on watching for warning signs in the younger populations, but have come to learn that it is becoming increasingly more prevalent in geriatrics due to chronic medical concerns, lack of family or friends, loneliess, undiagnosed mental illness, etc.

    Take care!

  2. I have been doing quite well myself. I have this dream of working full-time and coming off Social Security Disability. I have been working full-time at this place and just experienced getting laid off. It is not my fault, but the thoughts of my past and part of me see’s this as a failure. After 19 months remission, some suicidal thoughts have returned. For me it is not necessarily the worse situation, but a moment where my hope was lost. For a moment my dream of success was gone. I must be careful not to put my hope is circumstances, but trust that all things work to the good for those who love God. Romans 8:28

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s