Viewing the Nativity

Saw The Nativity with friends and family on Sunday. For Hollywood, I was impressed by their lack of taking liberties with the story. I would recommend seeing it. The actors portraying Herod and Joseph did fine jobs. You really see Herod’s paranoia and Joseph’s struggle. Mary is well portrayed. I left thinking about how old Mary was. Likely young. Imagine explaining to your husband-to-be and family that the Holy Spirit impregnated her. Yeah, right, Mary, tell us another one. Mary’s father does his best to make it acceptable by trying to get her to admit it was Herod’s soldiers. How did she not get stoned? Throughout the story, the magi add some comic relief to an otherwise grim story.  

The birth takes place in a cave, another likelihood given the geography of the area. What bothered my kids the most (6 and 8 years old)? Not Herod’s soldiers getting ready to kill the boys but the birth scenes. Elizabeth and Mary groan and struggle briefly. Their pain bothered them. As a bonus the ride home offered the opportunity to have a little conversation about sex and how babies are born.

Two things were out of place. First, Mary’s teeth are snow white, flashing every time she talked. Not likely. Though I was happy to see they used a middle-eastern looking cast. Lots of lovely brown skin and eyes everywhere. Second, the scenes of the trip to Jerusalem and then on to Egypt were portrayed like Sahara Desert dunes. The Israeli wilderness is a beautiful but not commonly dunes.

Still a worthwhile movie and one that makes the Christmas story come to life.  And another reminder that Herod belongs  in our nativity scenes (thanks Erik Larsen for pointing that out).


Filed under Movies

2 responses to “Viewing the Nativity

  1. I’ve often wondered about the white Jesus and the accuracy of those portrayals. However, with most images of the Israeli people being white today it seems a satisfactory portrayal (aside from the fact that I am white). When I saw the previews for The Nativity that was one of things that stood out to me, are they the right color? You mentioned seeing, “Lots of lovely brown skin and eyes everywhere”, and so I wondered what your take on that was. In the end, the incarnation of the living God transcends all races and that is enough for me. Just curious about your point of view.

    Sounds like your boys have a lot of empathy for mommies now 🙂

  2. Jeff, I think I probably could have been more specific on the skin color (olive/brown) but I do think that after 400 years in Egypt and the intermarriage with the Moabitess (Ruth) in Jeus lineage, its likely that he was a lot darker than what white christians portray in paintings of Jesus. The truth is we just don’t know. But he probably didn’t have blue eyes and probably did have wavy hair and its not out of the realm of possibility that he could have looked darker than some other Israelites.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.